Shelby and Nathaniel Wisely
Two Dates, Ten Years and One Loving Redeemer
Each year, there’s a new calendar — another clean slate of 365 days. Yet as we go through life, some dates take on more meaning than others. Two unforgettable dates remind Shelby and Nathaniel Wisely of God’s graciousness, of how He can heal our hearts, and of His unexpected gifts. Here’s their story — one that spans 10 years and ends in a miracle.
August 30
Shelby and Nathaniel married in May 2015 after their junior year of college. A few months later, Shelby learned she was pregnant, which didn’t necessarily align with the couple’s plans of waiting to start a family.
“We were shocked and scared,” she said. Yet over the course of two weeks, both Shelby and Nathaniel — and their families — became very excited about the baby.
Sadly, Shelby started having cramps, intense pain and bleeding. Doctors said she had an ectopic pregnancy, and there was nothing they could do. The baby could not survive outside the womb. They lost the child on August 30.
“After we lost the baby, I had a difficult time understanding my emotions. It was a roller coaster,” Shelby said. “In my head, God gave us this unexpected gift. He helped us get over our fear and get excited about it, and then it was taken away from us.”
Even after healing physically, she realized she wasn’t healing spiritually. She still trusted in Him, but she wanted to keep a certain distance, to protect herself from future heartache. It became difficult for her to trust His plan.
Meanwhile, as Shelby and Nathaniel grieved the loss of their first child, a mentor suggested naming the baby to help with the grieving process. The couple named her Lily.
“My boss at the time sent us lilies in the mail,” Shelby said, “so our apartment smelled beautiful. We’ve kept that as our tradition, and Nathaniel remembers to get lilies on that day. It brings back that memory and makes us feel close to her.”
April 22
The experience changed Nathaniel and Shelby’s family planning: they decided they wanted children sooner rather than later. Even so, when Shelby became pregnant with James in the spring of their senior year of college, they were anxious. Shelby’s chance for having another ectopic pregnancy was now 1 in 10, rather than 1 in 100, since she’d already experienced one.
But God gave them a dose of joy on the way to their first ultrasound appointment, because Shelby noticed the date. “We were in the car, and I said, ‘Wait! It’s April 22!’”
April 22 was Lily’s due date.
“We didn’t schedule that, the doctors did,” explained Shelby. “And James was healthy and great, and we got to experience the redemption of seeing a heartbeat on the screen.”
Although the couple said they will never forget Lily, they felt God lift away some of the sorrow of that particular calendar day. Now it also marked the joy of a perfectly healthy pregnancy.
“We saw God redeeming that day,” said Nathaniel, a self-professed numbers guy. “The dates carry a lot of meaning for us.”
Shelby said she thought having a healthy baby would “fix” the ache in her heart from losing Lily, but it didn’t completely. Nor did it break down the protective wall she built that kept her from fully trusting God’s plan.
Wrestling
At the beginning of their marriage, the Wisely’s agreed that four children was a good goal. Three years after having James, Shelby gave birth to Elliot. Both parents were thrilled that James would have a playmate.
But when Shelby became pregnant with Joshua — boy number three — she wrestled hard with her deep desire for a girl. The years were passing, and they would soon be nearing what in their minds was the final pregnancy. Shelby questioned God’s plan for her as a mom.
Struggling with those difficult emotions did not negate Shelby’s deep love for her sons.
“Every kid of ours is different, and I can say that we were meant to have these kids,” Shelby said. “When we found out Joshua was a boy, it was really hard, but he is such a gift.”
One year as the Wisely’s helped at a youth conference, a speaker shared Psalm 40:1-3. “It helped me remember to wait patiently,” Shelby said, “and that God hears my cry. He would help put a new song in my heart even though I was deep in despair.”
Shelby didn’t want to feel jealous every time God gave a baby girl to another couple. She wanted to feel joyful, not resentful. When her best friend gave birth to a girl, even then the discontentment remained. “I prayed and prayed for a long time,” Shelby explained. She asked God, “Can you just take this bitterness away?”
For Nathaniel, the desire to have a girl didn’t carry the same weight. His deepest desire was for his wife to “to trust the Lord, first and foremost,” he said, “and to see His faithfulness, even when He's not answering prayers the way that we want them to be answered — to still have that trust in His good plan.”
Loss
Shelby’s longing for a baby girl has roots in the loss of her father. Her parents divorced when she was 11, and Shelby’s dad left.
“I didn’t have a dad around, and it was hard. It was just me and my mom,” she explained. “I knew that God loved me, but I already really struggled with trust because of my dad.”
After she became a Christian during her high school years, she said she grew comfortable with the feeling that God was her Heavenly Father. Since the age of 16, she then prayed that God would allow her to witness her future husband be a loving earthly father to their daughter.
Yet with each child the couple had, Shelby said she felt “one step closer” to not having her dream realized.
“In my head, I'm praying this redemptive prayer,” Shelby recalled. Why would you not say yes, God? she thought. “Not that He had to, but I was wrestling with it and trying to understand. I have this dream and this prayer and this deep longing — why is it not being fulfilled?”
Shelby had seen her husband be a good dad to their boys. “He loves his kids so deeply,” she said. But she dreamed of being able to watch a daughter running to a father for comfort.
She admits that the loss of her father and the couple’s first child had wounded her. As she tried to make sense of the losses and grow closer to God, she sought therapy and prayer support. She listened to mentors and took part in the Celebrate Recovery program at Valley Free Evangelical Free Church in Chaska, Minnesota, where they are now members.
“As we were wrestling with this, I was thinking, Is my faith strong enough to have another boy?” Shelby said.
The Miracle
A couple of months before the couple started trying for baby number four, God intervened.
“God just worked on my heart,” Shelby recalled. “I wish I remembered the catalyst of it, but I don’t. I just woke up one morning and told Nathaniel ‘I think I’m going to be okay if it’s a boy.’”
In her heart, she trusted Jesus to choose the gender of their child.
“It was a complete 180, and I have no idea why,” Shelby recalled. “That’s why we wanted to share this story. That’s the miracle of it. The miracle is not that Emma (their fourth child) was an answer to prayer. The miracle came before we even got pregnant!”
Keep in mind that Shelby never saw herself as a “boy” mom. She hates bugs and being outside, and she doesn’t take the fish off the hook when they fish. Yet after she awoke that day, she found herself feeling excited to welcome boy number four, despite there being a bin full of donated baby girl clothes sitting in her basement — clothes from nieces that had been untouched for years.
Suddenly, she was excited to envision four boys playing together.
Before that day, she was still wrestling with her desire and wasn’t sure God was completely on her side. She had started asking Jesus to take away her longing for a baby girl. She wanted the trust wall between her and God to disappear.
That morning, she knew God had changed her heart and demolished the wall.
“It was like a flip of a switch,” she recalled. “I had tried everything to fix my relationship with God, to fix this barrier. And He was like, You know what? You can stop doing stuff. I'll just do it for you.”
“I had tried to work through the hole that was still there from my dad and Lily,” Shelby explained. “I tried therapy multiple times; I was trying everything. But in the end, it was God who did it. It was like God said, I’m the strong one, and I love you so much. I’m going to help you.”
“It wasn’t me at all,” Shelby said.
Unexpected Gift
God had graciously healed Shelby’s heart, and she was filled with thankfulness.
“Before we even got pregnant, we prayed on April 22, ‘Thank you so much for the three children we already have, and for the one you're going to give us. We know it’s going to be the one you want us to complete our family with,” Shelby said. She began preparing to have a boy.
And then, two months after they learned Shelby was pregnant, they opened the email with the gender results.
“Congratulations, it’s a girl!” they read.
“We were screaming and jumping around,” Shelby said with a laugh. “It was a wow moment. God answered our prayer, even though He healed my heart before that.”
The couple named their girl Emma Grace. Shelby had chosen the name “Emma” while she was in high school and first started praying about having a daughter. Nathaniel chose the name “Grace” to mark God’s graciousness throughout the ten years between Lily and Emma’s arrival a year ago.
In the spring of 2026, the Wiselys will be dedicating Emma to God at their church and remembering Lily on the ten-year anniversary of her due date.
For Nathaniel and Shelby, the two dates of August 30 and April 22 will also always remind them of one Loving Redeemer.